• About
  • Archive
  • Contact
  • Home 1
  • Submit a Story
  • Submit a Story
  • USCBC Podcasts
China Business Review
  • Operations
    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

  • Politics
    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    A Game of Chicken

    A Game of Chicken

  • Tech
    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    China’s Participation in International Standards Setting: Benefits and Concerns for US Industry

    China’s Participation in International Standards Setting: Benefits and Concerns for US Industry

    Trending Tags

    • Intellectual Property
    • innovation
    • cybersecurity
    • ecommerce
    • tech
  • Society
    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    Open Government Developments in China: Implications for US Businesses

  • Media

    Gallery: Craig Allen’s Trip to China

    USCBC 45th Annual Membership Meeting

    USCBC 45th Anniversary DC Open House

    USCBC President’s China Visit

    USCBC Hosts Business Roundtable with Zhejiang Party Secretary Che Jun

    USCBC hosts Comprehensive Economic Dialogue (CED) Luncheon

  • Podcasts
No Result
View All Result
  • Operations
    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

  • Politics
    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    A Game of Chicken

    A Game of Chicken

  • Tech
    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    China’s Participation in International Standards Setting: Benefits and Concerns for US Industry

    China’s Participation in International Standards Setting: Benefits and Concerns for US Industry

    Trending Tags

    • Intellectual Property
    • innovation
    • cybersecurity
    • ecommerce
    • tech
  • Society
    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    Open Government Developments in China: Implications for US Businesses

  • Media

    Gallery: Craig Allen’s Trip to China

    USCBC 45th Annual Membership Meeting

    USCBC 45th Anniversary DC Open House

    USCBC President’s China Visit

    USCBC Hosts Business Roundtable with Zhejiang Party Secretary Che Jun

    USCBC hosts Comprehensive Economic Dialogue (CED) Luncheon

  • Podcasts
No Result
View All Result
China Business Review
No Result
View All Result
Home Policy & Regulations

Inside the Beltway: High Frustrations, Low Rhetoric, and a Bad Bill

USCBC by USCBC
November 1, 2010
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedin

by John FrisbieA columnist at the Washington Post in late September called the US-China Business Council (USCBC), an organization of roughly 220 US companies that employ more than 7 million Americans, “un-American” for opposing, in USCBC’s opinion, counterproductive tariff legislation aimed at addressing China’s undervalued currency. During a September 29 House of Representatives debate, several members of Congress characterized the bill as being one that supported “real” Americans.

Frustrations are high on Capitol Hill and Election Day is close at hand, but that’s pretty strong rhetoric, even for Washington. There isn’t much disagreement about the desired result; it’s all about how we get there.

The House of Representatives passed the currency legislation in late September by a wide margin. The Senate did not act before it left for recess in October, but it could take up the issue during a “lame duck” session following the elections.

Like others, USCBC believes that China’s exchange rate should better reflect market influences from trade flows. But USCBC also believes that tariff legislation will be counterproductive to reaching that goal and will harm American manufacturers and farmers.

Why? Proposed legislative solutions require an estimate of the “true” value of the renminbi (RMB) and then assess tariff penalties to offset the undervaluation. The problem is that 10 different economists will give you 10 different exchange rate estimates; at best, only nine of them will be wrong. The approach is not only highly subjective, but also impractical. Exchange rates change daily; inflation rates, interest rates, and all the other factors that affect an exchange rate estimate also change frequently. How can a fixed-tariff penalty accommodate this fluctuating reality?

In addition, despite changes made to the bill in the House Ways and Means Committee, significant questions remain about whether addressing the exchange rate with countervailing duties would violate World Trade Organization (WTO) rules. Losing a WTO case would not strengthen our ability to sway China to make changes to its exchange rate policy.

USCBC further opposes the legislation because it will not achieve the purported goals of significantly reducing the trade deficit and creating jobs here at home. Much of the products we import from China are items that we imported from Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong, and Malaysia before. If the RMB exchange rate appreciates to the point that we no longer import something from China, in many—if not most—cases we will import it from somewhere else, not make it in the United States. The big winners from this legislation may turn out to be countries such as Thailand and Mexico.

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) backs up this point in its assessment of the bill: “CBO estimates that a small share of imports from [China] would be found to cause injury to domestic [US] firms,” because of limited overlap with US production.

US companies large and small have a host of other critical trade issues with China, such as intellectual property rights piracy, Buy China policies, and other market access barriers, that would likely get sidelined in a currency fight. The annual US-China Joint Commission on Commerce and Trade bilateral trade talks, an important channel to address these issues, are tentatively scheduled for mid-December. This tariff legislation could impede negotiations on other key commercial issues.

We should also assume that China will retaliate against US exports of manufactured goods and farm products if Congress takes unilateral action. Weathering retaliation might be worth it, if it achieves anything. Legislation that won’t get us to the goal, yet will harm American exports and jobs, just doesn’t seem like a win, however.

Rather than punishing China by punishing ourselves—or Congress picking winners and losers—we need to focus on less divisive ways to get results. The Obama administration is on the right course. Sustained bilateral and stepped up multilateral engagement with China on this issue, as well as dealing with other global imbalances, is critical to addressing the fundamentals driving the US trade balance.

Dissatisfaction with China is high, but tariff legislation will not help China’s exchange rate better reflect market influences from trade flows. Let’s hope wiser minds prevail in the Senate. Engagement might not be politically expedient or feel like the right solution on the campaign trail, but counterproductive legislation will not help us reach the intended goals of the supporters of the House currency vote.

Name calling won’t get us there either. Since when did it become “un-American” to point out the fallacies of bad policy?

[author] John Frisbie is president of the US-China Business Council. [/author]

Tags: CurrencyLetter from WashingtonRenminbi
USCBC

USCBC

Next Post

Do You Know the Deputy Chief Engineer of Bengbu's Economic and Industry Commission?

Recommended.

Reflections on the Phase One Agreement

January 20, 2022

Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

November 29, 2021

From Reshoring to Rightshoring: Dr. Sara Hsu on the Future of US-China Supply Chains

August 4, 2021

China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

July 22, 2021

Latest Podcasts.

What does the Indo-Pacific Economic Framework for Prosperity actually entail?

June 28, 2022

A benchmark on how companies are coping with Omicron

May 18, 2022

How companies are approaching China’s changing cyber landscape

May 12, 2022

What does the future of US-China decoupling look like?

May 5, 2022
China Business Review

China Business Review is the official magazine of the US-China Business Council, a nonprofit and nonpartisan trade association that represents more than 200 American companies doing business in China.

  • How to contribute to China Business Review

Categories

  • Bilateral Relations
  • Business Etiquette
  • CBR Spotlight
  • China Deals
  • Corruption
  • Cybersecurity
  • Ecommerce
  • Environment
  • Finance
  • Galleries
  • Getting Started
  • HR & Staffing
  • Infographics
  • Innovation
  • Intellectual Property
  • Management
  • Media
  • Operations
  • Opinion
  • Policy & Regulations
  • Politics
  • PR & Marketing
  • Rural Issues
  • Safety
  • Social Policy
  • Society
  • Standards + Licensing
  • Sustainability
  • Tax
  • Tech
  • Top Story
  • Trade
  • Uncategorized
  • US-China Business Council
  • Videos

Tags

Agreements Agriculture Alibaba Best Practices Business Environment China China's Investments Abroad China Market Intelligence Chinese Consumers Chinese Investment Commentary Consumer Trends E-Commerce Economic Trends Energy Environment Events Food Foreign Investment Going Global Healthcare Reform Human Resources Infrastructure Internet Interview Investment Investments into China IPO Joint Venture Labor Legal Analysis M&A Manufacturing Media National People's Congress Q&A Strategic and Economic Dialogue Supply Chains Technology Trade Transparency US-China Relations USCBC US Exports to China Xi Jinping

Join our Mailing List

Sign up for the US-China Business Council's newsletters to stay ahead of the game with roundups, analysis, and commentary.

Sign Up

Follow Us

  • About
  • USCBC
  • Submit a Story
  • Archive

© 2021 China Business Review

No Result
View All Result
  • Operations
  • Politics
  • Tech
  • Society
  • Media
  • Podcasts

© 2021 China Business Review