• About
  • Archive
  • China Business Review Historical Archive
  • Contact
  • Home 1
  • Submit a Story
  • Submit a Story
  • USCBC Podcasts
China Business Review
  • Operations
    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

  • Politics
    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    A Game of Chicken

    A Game of Chicken

  • Tech
    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    Trending Tags

    • Intellectual Property
    • innovation
    • cybersecurity
    • ecommerce
    • tech
  • Society
    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    Open Government Developments in China: Implications for US Businesses

  • Media

    Gallery: Craig Allen’s Trip to China

    USCBC 45th Annual Membership Meeting

    USCBC 45th Anniversary DC Open House

    USCBC President’s China Visit

    USCBC Hosts Business Roundtable with Zhejiang Party Secretary Che Jun

    USCBC hosts Comprehensive Economic Dialogue (CED) Luncheon

  • Podcasts
  • Archive
No Result
View All Result
  • Operations
    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

  • Politics
    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    A Game of Chicken

    A Game of Chicken

  • Tech
    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    Trending Tags

    • Intellectual Property
    • innovation
    • cybersecurity
    • ecommerce
    • tech
  • Society
    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    Open Government Developments in China: Implications for US Businesses

  • Media

    Gallery: Craig Allen’s Trip to China

    USCBC 45th Annual Membership Meeting

    USCBC 45th Anniversary DC Open House

    USCBC President’s China Visit

    USCBC Hosts Business Roundtable with Zhejiang Party Secretary Che Jun

    USCBC hosts Comprehensive Economic Dialogue (CED) Luncheon

  • Podcasts
  • Archive
No Result
View All Result
China Business Review
No Result
View All Result
Home Bilateral Relations

Is China a ‘Market Economy?’ It doesn’t matter.

USCBC by USCBC
April 26, 2016

Flags of USA and China and faces of Benjamin Franklin and Mao Zedong with displays of daily stock market prices and quotations. The two biggest economic countries in the world. Financial Concept.

Share on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedin

By John Frisbie and Erin Ennis

Based on the headlines in the trade press recently, you might get the idea that the United States faces an influx of massive amounts of Chinese steel at the end of this year, thanks to an obscure provision in China’s WTO accession protocol about market economy status.

The widely cited but poorly understood provision will not leave us defenseless to steel or any other products flooding the U.S. market. But mishandling this important issue could damage our credibility and impact U.S.-China relations for years to come. Fortunately, there is a way out – and the question of whether China is a “market economy” has nothing to do with it.

When China joined the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 2001, its government’s pervasive intervention in the economy meant that China’s trading partners could not trust data on the true cost of production and determine a fair market value in anti-dumping cases. A provision in China’s accession agreement resolved this issue by allowing other WTO member countries to use special tariff calculations, known in the U.S. as non-market economy (NME) calculations, in China cases—for a period of 15 years. As a result, the U.S. could use a formula to determine the value of anti-dumping tariffs to apply to Chinese goods sold at unfairly low prices. That provision is set to expire Dec. 11, 2016.

Despite the current rhetoric, that much of the situation is indisputable. Three successive U.S. administrations — all that have served during and since China joined the WTO — have stated over and over again in public and in official documents that the ability to use NME calculations ends after 15 years. As late as 2012, the Obama Administration explained the provision in its annual report to Congress on China’s WTO compliance,

“China’s accession agreement also includes provisions establishing several mechanisms… designed to prevent or remedy injury that U.S. or other WTO members’ industries and workers might experience based on import surges or unfair trade practices. These mechanisms include…the authority for WTO members whose national laws contain market economy criteria as of the date of China’s WTO accession to utilize a special non-market economy methodology for measuring dumping in anti-dumping cases against Chinese companies (this China-specific authority expires after 15 years, running from the date of China’s WTO accession).”

This commitment was integral to getting final agreement with China at the highest levels on the terms of its WTO entry. End-stage negotiations with then-Premier Zhu Rongji specifically included this provision and its definitive end date to close the deal. Breaking the commitment would be enormously detrimental to American interests on other more significant issues with China, and would also encourage the Chinese to think that breaking commitments is acceptable behavior – not a message the United States should convey.

Parts of China’s economy are now functioning as a market economy. At the same time, we can all agree that there are parts of China’s economy that continue to function contrary to market principles. For example, by its own admission, China has significant overcapacity in products such as steel and aluminum. Those industries have benefited from favorable subsidies and other government intervention, with a detrimental effect on both international and China’s own domestic markets.

The key to the current discussion is in what comes next. Many have argued over whether China meets the criteria under U.S. law to be treated as a market economy. A closer reading of China’s WTO accession protocol reveals that this question is irrelevant. The language in the protocol does not require the U.S. to name China as a market economy in December; it simply requires ending the use of the NME methodology – an important distinction that suggests a path forward.

There are several principles that should guide how the U.S. can best approach this issue — a middle ground that would enable us to both meet our WTO commitment and address the clear distortions that some sectors of China’s economy are still creating not only in China but also in global markets:

  1. Honor the commitment and end the use of blanket, across-the-board NME methodology.
  2. Be WTO compliant.
  3. Retain our ability to apply U.S. trade remedies when necessary and fact-based.
  4. Not be China-specific – what’s good for China ought to be good to do for any trade partner.
  5. Not require changing U.S. law.

One solution that would appear to fit the above criteria was included in legislation passed by Congress last summer. Section 504 of the Trade Preferences Extension Act, which was signed in to law on June 29, 2015, expanded Commerce’s discretion to assess “particular market situations” in anti-dumping investigations, and to use methodologies other than strict comparisons with domestic prices and costs when it finds that those particular market situations would prevent a proper comparison.

In other words, rather than using non-market methodologies across the board and in all cases, Commerce could use this authority to address the distortions that may remain in some sectors of China’s economy – just as it can do in cases involving other trading partner economies.

There would need to be a rigorous, grounded process for demonstrating a sector or producer qualifies for using an alternative methodology, to avoid simply using this approach for protectionist purposes. The alternative methodology would need to be WTO compliant, but the U.S. has many gifted trade lawyers who should be able to craft an approach to meet this bar. We should also be talking bluntly to the Chinese government, pointing out that we will honor the commitment – and clarifying what that commitment is – yet we will still take steps to ensure their overcapacity problem is not exported to us.

Rather than wasting more time arguing over what the U.S. does not need to do on Dec. 11, we should honor the commitment that three successive administrations have articulated and focus our energy on finding the effective, middle ground solution – a solution which fits squarely into US interests by addressing the distortions of China’s overcapacity in certain sectors and ensuring that US-China relations remain on stable footing.

 

 

John Frisbie is president of the US-China Business Council. Erin Ennis is senior vice president.

Tags: Anti-DumpingEconomymarketTrade PracticesWorld Trade Organization
USCBC

USCBC

Next Post

Obtaining a Certificate of Origin in China: Application Procedure and Administrative Measures

Recommended.

China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

August 5, 2022

Reflections on the Phase One Agreement

January 20, 2022

Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

November 29, 2021

From Reshoring to Rightshoring: Dr. Sara Hsu on the Future of US-China Supply Chains

August 4, 2021

Latest Podcasts.

What recent chip export controls mean for business

January 25, 2023

Taking stock as we enter USCBC’s 50th year

January 13, 2023

What unexpected midterm results mean for China policy

November 16, 2022

Two tales of travel to China

November 7, 2022
China Business Review

China Business Review is the official magazine of the US-China Business Council, a nonprofit and nonpartisan trade association that represents more than 200 American companies doing business in China.

  • How to contribute to China Business Review

Categories

  • Bilateral Relations
  • Business Etiquette
  • CBR Spotlight
  • China Deals
  • Corruption
  • Cybersecurity
  • Ecommerce
  • Environment
  • Finance
  • Galleries
  • Getting Started
  • HR & Staffing
  • Infographics
  • Innovation
  • Intellectual Property
  • Management
  • Media
  • Operations
  • Opinion
  • Policy & Regulations
  • Politics
  • PR & Marketing
  • Rural Issues
  • Safety
  • Social Policy
  • Society
  • Standards + Licensing
  • Sustainability
  • Tax
  • Tech
  • Top Story
  • Trade
  • Uncategorized
  • US-China Business Council
  • Videos

Tags

Agreements Agriculture Alibaba Best Practices Business Environment China China's Investments Abroad China Market Intelligence Chinese Consumers Chinese Investment Commentary Consumer Trends E-Commerce Economic Trends Energy Environment Events Food Foreign Investment Going Global Healthcare Reform Human Resources Infrastructure Internet Interview Investment Investments into China IPO Joint Venture Labor Legal Analysis M&A Manufacturing Media National People's Congress Q&A Strategic and Economic Dialogue Supply Chains Technology Trade Transparency US-China Relations USCBC US Exports to China Xi Jinping

Join our Mailing List

Sign up for the US-China Business Council's newsletters to stay ahead of the game with roundups, analysis, and commentary.

Sign Up

Follow Us

  • About
  • USCBC
  • Submit a Story
  • Archive

© 2022 China Business Review

No Result
View All Result
  • Operations
  • Politics
  • Tech
  • Society
  • Media
  • Podcasts
  • Archive

© 2022 China Business Review